23 Comments
User's avatar
John Glavin's avatar

I stumbled on this today. Terra Nullius is a History Nerd's dream. Looking forward to reading more!

Expand full comment
Ned Donovan's avatar

Great to have you John!

Expand full comment
Patrick Smith's avatar

Thanks for doing Poyais! It's a fascinating cautionary tale. I believe some of MacGregor's victims actually *defended him* after they made it back, because the cognitive dissonance wouldn't let them believe how they'd been straightforwardly taken in. They needed to believe it was real, that's a familiar psychology of fraud victims. From Scotland's point of view, to have one disastrous attempt to colonise Central America could be misfortune - but to have two (Darien and Poyais) looks like carelessness...

Expand full comment
Ned Donovan's avatar

You’re very right! Amazing that really he never faced any consequences

Expand full comment
antoinette.uiterdijk's avatar

Investors, bankers, mortgage-lenders/brokers, who helped cause the 2008 financial disaster never face consequences either. They were allowed to keep their ill-gotten bonuses. The "small" people, who thought they had a chance to give their children a better future too, paid the price. Losing their savings, then their house, and often also their job. Many never recovered from their losses.

Expand full comment
Jane Baker's avatar

This must be the bank crisis depicted in the book Cranford by Mrs Gaskell in which the genteel Miss Matty and her friends,already discreetly poor lose what little money they do have.

Expand full comment
antoinette.uiterdijk's avatar

Don't know about Ms. Matty, it sounds like a (good) story. I will check it out ! But I was talking about the real thing, that caused so much misery for so many people. No one went to prison, no one paid a fine. Worse, the people duped, were told they had themselves too blame.

Expand full comment
Jane Baker's avatar

Things don't change do they!

Expand full comment
antoinette.uiterdijk's avatar

Sadly, for ordinary people they don't.

Expand full comment
Michael Jensen's avatar

I absolutely love learning about historical episodes like this that had somehow escaped my attention. Thankfully people have learned their lesson and no one would be this gullible today. LOL LOL

Expand full comment
Ned Donovan's avatar

Ha!

Expand full comment
Jane Baker's avatar

Ha ha!

Expand full comment
Maxi Gorynski's avatar

McGregor had one of the most extraordinary psychologies of any man - so much resource, so much dare-and-dash, as could have helped him achieve a breathtaking array of legitimate successes, who nonetheless seemed to be fuelled by pleasure compulsively taken in getting one over on other people.

May my word be kept as given here - I will novelise his life one day.

Expand full comment
Ned Donovan's avatar

Better print this out

Expand full comment
Jane Baker's avatar

Very Flashman

Expand full comment
Ted Morris's avatar

Fascinating - nice piece

Expand full comment
Ned Donovan's avatar

Thanks Ted!

Expand full comment
Vernon's avatar

Wow! What an imagination!

Expand full comment
M. E. Rothwell's avatar

What a great story!

Expand full comment
Ned Donovan's avatar

Loved your email today too

Expand full comment
M. E. Rothwell's avatar

Thanks man!

Expand full comment
Brian's avatar

Such a unique story. Crazy the life paths people will end up on! Thanks for the read.

Expand full comment
Jane Baker's avatar

And full of thriving wildlife I hope. We never learn do we. All that sort of thing is going on right now,on a global scale,but all who call it out get stigmatized as disseminators of "disinformation and "misinformation".

Expand full comment